I purchased both Lilac Talk and Rose Preset on sale—let's just say I'm glad I didn't pay full price. Both palettes have beautifully nuanced, muted shades and a super silky texture that seems to glide on effortlessly without threatening to become patchy, almost like a blurring setting powder for the eyelids. However, their fatal flaw is that they're almost laughably lacking in pigment, even relative to my other Korean eyeshadows; I would sooner describe them as tinted powders rather than full on eyeshadows. They're not necessarily nonexistent, but I definitely have to work to get them to show up. I will say that the texture is conducive to this process, though, as layering the shadow doesn't cause it to become cakey, but I'm also inclined to think that its blendability is due in part to its super sheer pigment. For context, I have fair/light olive skin and typically sit at around 21-22 in Korean base products, so the fact that I'm breaking a sweat to get the colors to be discernible is a little unacceptable to me (to give them the benefit of the doubt, however, I have not yet tried them with an eyeshadow primer, so there's a possibility that they'll pop more on top of one). There's something to be said about how the shadow's sheerness serves to impart a watercolor effect that's more trendy in Korean makeup, and there is definitely something beautiful and sophisticated about the look. However, I would advise that those with skin any deeper than mine think twice about purchasing these colorways, at least, as I can't speak to the others.